Which vacuum cleaner is better - with a bag or a container?

Rating of the best vacuum cleaners of 2020

Which cyclone or bagged vacuum cleaner would you choose or recommend purchasing?

Take the survey

Vacuum cleaners with a dust bag

About half a century ago, the first model of a vacuum cleaner with a dust bag was invented. It is into the bag that all sucked-up debris gets caught during cleaning. Such models remain in high demand to this day. Since the invention of the first models, bagged vacuum cleaners have improved and become more convenient and functional. Now, such models can not only vacuum the floor, but also clean carpets, furniture, curtains and even windows.

There are two types of bags:

1. Disposable
2. Reusable

Disposable bags are made of synthetic or paper. They are good because you can easily clean the vacuum cleaner; to do this, you just need to throw out the filled bag. Reusable bags are made of fabric. They will take a little longer to clean, but they can be used an unlimited number of times and some are even machine washable.

pros

To begin with, it is worth noting the advantages of bagged vacuum cleaners for collecting dust . It’s not for nothing that these models remain in demand to this day, since they have quite a lot of positive aspects.

• Easy to use. Thanks to their simple design, these models are easy to maintain and repair. After use, the vacuum cleaner does not need to be wiped or washed. Simply clean the bag and put it back in place. As for repairs, anyone, even a less experienced one, can figure it out.
• Hygiene. Oddly enough, bag models are still considered the most hygienic. Provided that everything is made according to the rules, the bag will not allow dust to pass through. In addition, if you paid attention to manufacturers' statements, you probably heard about several stages of filtration. Most of them relate specifically to bags.
• Easy cleaning. If you choose a model with disposable bags, cleaning will not take much time. It will be enough to simply throw the used bag in the trash and replace it with a new one.
• Power. When comparing vacuum cleaners with bags and containers, it is clear that the former have stronger suction power. This happens because the bag allows air to pass through it, while cyclonic models inevitably lose power. However, it is worth considering that as the bag fills, the power will decrease.
• Low noise level. Unlike models with a container, bagged vacuum cleaners are much quieter. This occurs due to the increase in distance as air passes inside.

Minuses

Do not forget about the disadvantages , which, as a rule, manufacturers and sellers of equipment are silent about.

• Consumables. When using disposable bags, you will have to constantly repurchase them. The problem is not only the waste of money, but also the difficulty of finding it. Each model requires special consumables. This is especially problematic if the model is rare and bags for it are not particularly popular.
• Power. As mentioned above, despite the good suction power, it decreases as the bag fills.
• Fragility. This applies to reusable bags as they may break over time. You need to be careful when using it and have an extra bag in stock in case the main one fails.

This is interesting! Zelmer washing vacuum cleaners with aquafilter - types and characteristics

Customer Reviews

To make your choice easier, it is best to refer to reviews from other customers. They can talk about using bagged vacuum cleaners based on personal experience.

In my opinion, it is best to use a model with disposable bags. There really aren’t any problems here; you can easily throw away the bag after cleaning and that’s it. I initially used reusable bags, but quickly abandoned them. Too much dust before you shake it out, especially inconvenient if you don’t have a balcony or yard where you can do it. My advice is to spend a little, but buy disposable bags.

Kate

After a year of using a vacuum cleaner with a container, we replaced it with a bag one. There is more hassle with the container until you shake everything out, wash it and dry it. And then I vacuumed it several times, shook out the bag and that’s it.

Andrey

The best inexpensive cyclone vacuum cleaners

LG VK76A02NTL

LG VK76A02NTL
The rating of inexpensive cyclonic vacuum cleaners with a container opens with a quite good model from LG, which stands out not only for its low price, but also for its quite good characteristics. It should be noted that the suction power in this model is 380 W, which is quite good for a budget vacuum cleaner, and a cyclonic one at that.

It should also be noted its high power consumption, which is not encouraging. But in general, if high suction suits you, then the model is quite good.

LG VK76A02NTL has a nice design. It makes the vacuum cleaner seem compact. This model has excellent maneuverability, and one of the reasons for this is its lightness.

The removable container is quite large – only one and a half liters. And thanks to the filtration system, which is called Ellipse Cyclone, the vacuum cleaner model from LG will be able to effectively separate dust microparticles from the air, which would not hurt at all. The combination with a HEPA 11 fine filter only attracts more attention to this model.

An eight-meter radius due to the length of the cord is enough to clean the entire room. Ergonomics allows you to assemble the cord itself with one button, make a tube of the desired length, and also remove everything using various attachments.

The model is worth considering. It absorbs well, cleans well, and caring for it is simple and straightforward.

pros

• quality manufacturer;
• nice price;
• good design;
• multi-level filtration;
• easy container cleaning.

Minuses

• no power regulator;
• makes noise when working.

LG VK76A02NTL

Midea VCS43C4

Midea VCS43C4
In third place, due to its low price and low brand awareness, is a model from the Midea company, which offers the future owner high quality characteristics, including suction power (only 400 W), as well as the power of the entire vacuum cleaner, which is 2200 W, which is quite A lot for a small vacuum cleaner.

The Midea VCS43C4 cyclonic vacuum cleaner has a pleasant design that resembles something futuristic, as if a vacuum cleaner is not from our time. At the same time, on the other hand, it resembles other, more well-known vacuum cleaners.

This model, interestingly, has a very capacious container - as much as three liters. This allows you to clean a lot and for a long time before it clogs. And it will be quite difficult to clog it, because in addition to the container itself, the vacuum cleaner has a HEPA 12 fine dust filter, which is more than good.

The cord is quite short in length (only five meters), and it automatically rewinds after cleaning. The vacuum cleaner pipe is not too long. Due to the set of attachments, the vacuum cleaner can be used almost everywhere, and with the turbo brush it is convenient to clean furniture.

Midea VCS43C4 is a model that deserves attention for its good basic characteristics and price.

pros

• good price;
• multi-level filtration for high-quality cleaning;
• smooth engine start;
• presence of overheating protection.

Minuses

• the suction power cannot be adjusted;
• The tube for the vacuum cleaner is inconvenient.

Midea VCS43C4

VITEK VT-8105

VITEK VT-8105
Second place goes to the well-deserving model of the “absolutely Russian” brand Vitek. The best vacuum cleaner from this company is the VT-8105 model, which is traditionally assembled in the Middle Kingdom. The size of the vacuum cleaner is not entirely compact, but changing the size to a larger size made it possible to greatly increase the size of the dust collector - up to five liters! Thanks to this, you rarely have to open the container itself and throw out all the garbage. What’s worse is that this same change in size greatly increases the weight of the vacuum cleaner – up to 6 kilograms.

Thanks to its size, it is possible to use, in addition to the HEPA filter, another one - a motor one. This allows you to clean everything in more detail with this vacuum cleaner. The model’s suction power is quite decent (as much as 350 W), but the power consumption is quite high, which means it will consume a lot of electricity.

The body has an on/off foot switch and a five-meter cord winding button. The equipment is not original: a hose, a telescope tube, a main nozzle with a choice of floor/carpet positions, a crevice brush, and a small brush for upholstered furniture. VITEK's warranty is standard 12 months.

pros

• Beautiful design;
• high suction power;
• smooth engine start;
• the presence of nozzle clamps on the handle of the vacuum cleaner;
• Possibility of placement in different planes for storage.

Minuses

• heavy weight of the vacuum cleaner;
• short power cord length.

VITEK VT-8105

BBK BV1503

BBK BV1503
In first place among the best inexpensive cyclone vacuum cleaners, the model from the Chinese company BBK wins. Model BV1503 is a very inexpensive cyclone vacuum cleaner. The “Chinese”, without any special ambitions, is full of diligence and diligently cleans, because he has everything he needs - first of all, hoses and brushes.

The tube is telescopic, it is not too difficult to prepare it for work. The power of 320 watts is enough for a good degree of cleanliness. This model has no adjustments.

Power consumption is quite classic for inexpensive models - 2000 W.

In addition to the container, BBK BV1503 has a built-in HEPA filter, which is responsible for fine air purification. This vacuum cleaner has good protection against overheating.

The design of the vacuum cleaner is quite simple, although there are two options. You can choose only bright red or black and gray.

pros

• still affordable price;
• good suction power;
• small sizes.

Minuses

• the power cable is too short;
• quite noisy.

Reviews and prices for BBK BV1503

You might be interested in knowing which hobs are best to buy .

Comparison of characteristics of vacuum cleaners with a bag and a container

Let's compare models of vacuum cleaners with a bag and with a container according to several of the most important indicators for use:

• The first indicator is simplicity and clarity of operation. Vacuum cleaners equipped with a disposable dust bag are considered the most convenient in this regard. This model does not need to be washed, dried and filters cleaned every time. The used bag is immediately thrown away and a new one is installed.
• In terms of the second parameter, namely operational efficiency, models with a container win. Devices with a bag lose power as the dust container becomes full. Vacuum cleaners with a container do not have this drawback; the dust suction power of such models is retained.
• The third parameter for comparison is hygiene. This characteristic is especially important for allergy sufferers and families with small children. The results here are not so clear-cut. The indoor air will be cleaner after using the device with the bag. But, if the bags are reusable, then when cleaning the dust collectors, it will be impossible to get rid of dust in the air and around. This fact practically eliminates the merit for better cleansing. Still, it must be recognized that it is more convenient to use models equipped with a dust container. In terms of cleaning, they are really more convenient.

The best cyclone vacuum cleaners

Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Parquet CY26

Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Parquet CY26
The fifth place among the best cyclonic vacuum cleaners was taken by a universal vacuum cleaner with a top quality build. Having a small set of attachments with him, the potential owner will, as a rule, use only four main ones.

1. Musclehead - for floors and carpets.
2. Furniture brush.
3. Movable brush for hard surfaces.
4. Combo nozzle.

The telescopic pipe can be adjusted, which is extremely convenient for further use. But the main “trick” is in a completely different thing. The vacuum cleaner can level itself and return to its previous position before it fell due to the center of gravity and the hinge located on the handle. It is also worth noting its heavy weight – 6.1 kg.

The suction power of this vacuum cleaner is quite low, which is very surprising - only 150 W. At the same time, it should be noted that the low, really low power consumption is 700 W, which indicates the “cost-effectiveness” of the device. But the most surprising thing is the very small size of the dust collector - only 0.8 liters.

Thanks to the exclusive Dyson Cinetic technology, this vacuum cleaner model is able to retain any, even the smallest, particle of dust, which is extremely useful if there are allergy sufferers in the family. At the same time, the suction power remains the same, since these particles are not able to clog the filter.

pros

• attractive appearance;
• meager set;
• easy filter maintenance;
• easy cleaning of debris;
• Dyson Cinetic technology and its effectiveness in combating allergies.

Minuses

• low suction power;
• small dust collector capacity;
• high noise level;
• heavy weight;
• inadequate price;
• Poor fixation of the dust collector.

Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Parquet CY26

Video – Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Parquet CY26

Bosch BGS2UPWER3

Bosch BGS2UPWER3
In fourth place among the best cyclone vacuum cleaners is the model from Bosch - BGS2UPWER3. Being compact and lightweight, this vacuum cleaner is quite maneuverable. And its stylish appearance only attracts and encourages you to buy.

Regarding the dust collector, this vacuum cleaner has a small one, only 1.4 liters, but caring for it is quite simple. It can be easily removed, cleaned and returned to its place.

Thanks to SensorBagless technology, which can only be found in Bosch vacuum cleaners, the BGS2UPWER3 model requires virtually no maintenance, except for the very minimum.

The suction power of this vacuum cleaner is 300 W, which is considered a pretty good indicator, although not the best. It should be noted that the high power consumption is 2500 W, which indicates the “gluttony” of the vacuum cleaner.

Experts from Obzor-expert.com explain how this technology works:

“The sensor built inside works non-stop, monitoring the level of air flow. When the indicators are reduced, the sensor sends a command to turn off and the vacuum cleaner stops working automatically. This activates the membrane filter cleaning system and operates until the cleaning is completed and, accordingly, the air flow level is restored.”

This vacuum cleaner has several key features, which will be discussed below. Firstly, it should be noted that there is a highly efficient dust separation system that helps in cleaning. Secondly, this vacuum cleaner has a more than good HEPA 13 filter, thanks to which the air in the house is cleaner, fresher and more pleasant. In addition, caring for this filter is simple - you just need to rinse and dry it.

pros

• electronic power adjustment controlled via a rotary controller on the body;
• telescopic tube made of metal;
• a sufficiently long power cable;
• SensorBagless technology with Sensor Control indicator.

Minuses

• poor set of attachments;
• loud noise when the filter clogs;
• “delicate”, can easily burn out;
• inability to control the operation of the vacuum cleaner through the handle.

Bosch BGS2UPWER3

Philips FC9351 PowerPro Compact

Philips FC9351 PowerPro Compact
In third place is another, albeit not the best, but still a good cyclonic vacuum cleaner from Philips.

The FC9351 PowerPro Compact, which is quite compact in size, has some notable features found in the larger versions. For example, high consumption is 1900 W. It should also be noted the high suction power – 370 W.

Thanks to the technology found in the Philips vacuum cleaner, called PowerCyclone 5, the vacuum cleaner has high performance in separating dust from the rest. The motor itself is protected by a washable filter, so it won't short out. In addition, the vacuum cleaner has an EPA 10 filter that does not let dirt and dust, even in the form of small particles, out.

The kit is quite simple, it has everything you need - a telescopic tube with a latch for the nozzle, a furniture brush, and, more importantly, a MultiClean nozzle for other types of floors.

In general, the vacuum cleaner is considered quite practical, easy to use, and its build quality, which is important, is quite high.

pros

• pleasant appearance;
• easy to maintain;
• the power cord is six meters long enough for a budget model;
• International guarantee for a period of two years.

Minuses

• there is no handle for carrying the vacuum cleaner;
• consumables are not cheap.

Philips FC9351 PowerPro Compact

Polaris PVC 1821WR

Polaris PVC 1821WR
The second place among the best cyclonic vacuum cleaners was taken by an ordinary, unremarkable vacuum cleaner from the point of view of the brand, which has a rather non-standard design and at the same time high suction power of 400 W. This allows this vacuum cleaner to immediately become a leader, since the suction power directly affects the quality of carpet cleaning.

This household vacuum cleaner has a power regulator. You can interact with it by setting the vacuum cleaner a specific program.

Polaris is doing well with its “appetite”, judging by the power consumption indicator - only 1800 W, however, with such suction power as this model, such a power consumption indicator is quite justified.

The Polaris PVC 1821 dust collector is quite capacious - two liters. This volume is enough to clean a small apartment at a time. That is, the dust collector can not be opened until the very end of cleaning.

Air quality is another criterion whose results will please you. HEPA 13 meets this very criterion, with which dust, even the smallest, remains inside and does not come out, which will be a real plus for allergy sufferers.

The model’s equipment is quite “Spartan” - there are only four attachments (for the floor, for hard-to-reach places, for dust, and also for cleaning upholstered furniture. A slightly short cord can interfere with cleaning the apartment. But with the wheels of the vacuum cleaner everything is fine - they large enough to overcome various kinds of obstacles.

pros

• adequate cost;
• good suction power;
• capacious filter;
• presence of HEPA13 filter;
• compact sizes.

Minuses

• lack of power regulator;
• short cord length of five meters;
• high power consumption;
• poor equipment in the form of nozzles for the floor and carpet, as well as crevice.

Polaris PVC 1821WR

Samsung VC18M3160

Samsung VC18M3160
In first place is the most interesting cyclone vacuum cleaner from Samsung, model VC18M3160, which can handle smooth surfaces and long-pile carpets.

Being powerful, inexpensive and compact, the Samsung VC18M3160 makes it easy and quick to deal with dirt and dust. First of all, it is necessary to note the high suction power - about 380 W, as well as low power consumption of 1800 W.

Its container, like the Polaris PVC 1821WR, is quite spacious - two liters, which allows you to clean an ordinary apartment without touching the dust container every 5 minutes.

Thanks to the exclusive Anti Tangle technology, the vacuum cleaner, while collecting all kinds of threads, dust and hair, prevents them from twisting and winding, which allows you to keep the suction power at the same level.

There are several important parts on the body of the vacuum cleaner. Firstly, there is a button, the rotation of which adjusts the power. Secondly, the ergonomic Easy Grip handle, with which the hose will no longer twist. In addition, cleaning becomes quite easy and quick, so you don’t even need to strain.

The equipment comes with a classic set – nozzles for floors and carpets, a turbo brush, a crevice brush and a dust brush.

pros

• good value;
• ergonomics;
• comfortable handle;
• large dust collector capacity;
• Anti-Tangle technology.

Minuses

• high noise level (87 dB).

Reviews and prices for Samsung VC18M3160

You may be interested in knowing which air conditioner to buy for your apartment .

Vacuum cleaner with a bag - device features

Every apartment or house, regardless of the surface and type of floors, the number of residents or the time we spend in it, needs to be vacuumed at least once a week. When purchasing, we have a dilemma about which model of household appliances to choose. A few years ago, we didn't have a choice between types of vacuum cleaners and our only decision was to choose the type of bag. The traditional vacuum cleaner with a bag is the oldest type, which still dominates among this type of home appliance. Today we have a choice between two types of bags:

1. paper ones, which should be changed regularly when they are completely filled;
2. textiles that can be reused because you simply throw away their contents to be able to use them again.

The use of textile and paper bags has its pros and cons. It is worth knowing them before making the final choice, because it affects both the cost of purchasing and operating the equipment, as well as the comfort and quality of work.

The bag should be cleaned frequently. It's not a difficult job, but it's certainly not the most enjoyable. We often get lazy and don't clean it systematically as required according to the manufacturer's instructions. Paper bags seem to be a much smarter choice because they are more hygienic. However, we are in a dilemma regarding further expenses as we have to buy them regularly.

Textile bags relatively rarely require replacement, but such a solution is not only unhygienic and inconvenient. After some time, dirt accumulates in them and minor damage occurs, while not all of the dust ends up in the bag, some of it penetrates inside the device. At best, the device simply gets dirty, and at worst, dirt can penetrate inside in large quantities, the device may work worse or even break.

In modern models, regardless of the type of bag, there is often an additional filter (HEPA), which protects people with allergies from the smallest dust particles that pass through the bag. This filter purifies exhaust air up to 95 percent.

Advantages and disadvantages of paper bags

Advantages:

• convenient and easy replacement, just throw the filled bag in the trash and replace it with a new one;
• eliminating the need to empty the bag significantly reduces human contact with dust.

Flaws:

• the need for regular replacement leads to additional costs.

Advantages and disadvantages of textile bags

Flaws:

• direct human contact with dust and dirt during emptying and cleaning the bag;
• Over time, holes may appear in the bag through which some of the dust will penetrate out.

Advantages:

• no costs associated with regular purchases of new bags;
• The best quality bags have a coating that protects against dust and dirt spilling when the bag is removed from the vacuum cleaner.

Best bagged vacuum cleaners 2021

Today, bagged vacuum cleaners remain as popular as ever. They are cheaper, time-tested and perform their functions just as effectively as before.

Below are five models that you should definitely pay attention to.

SUPRA VCS-1601

SUPRA VCS-1601
Fifth place is occupied by the VCS-1601 model from Supra, known for its quality and affordable price. The vacuum cleaner itself is quite simple in appearance. But under this appearance there is a fairly high suction power (300 W), which provides high-quality cleaning and not too high power consumption - around 1600 W.

Due to the convenient telescopic pipe, the vacuum cleaner is quite convenient to operate. A reusable bag for collecting garbage and dust allows you to not think about replacing it for some time. The bag itself is quite roomy for a budget vacuum cleaner - two and a half liters. This is enough for a maximum of three cleanings, then you will have to replace the bag with another one.

This model has a dust bin full indicator. It will make it clear when to stop and clean it before continuing to clean.

The vacuum cleaner's equipment is sparse - only two attachments. One is for cleaning cracks and hard-to-reach places, the other is for carpet and floors.

pros

• adequate price;
• high suction power;
• overheating protection system in the form of automatic shutdown of the vacuum cleaner;
• presence of a bag full indicator;
• spacious dust bag;
• high build quality;
• compactness.

Minuses

• short power cord;
• flimsy body;
• persistent smell of plastic;
• lack of power adjustment;
• makes a lot of noise.

SUPRA VCS-1601

Samsung SC4140

Samsung SC4140
In fourth place is the SC4140 model from Samsung, which is able to prove that even the economy segment can offer wide functionality.

Indeed, this vacuum cleaner is capable of not only sucking in, but also blowing out air. This will be very useful when cleaning hard-to-reach places.

In addition, this vacuum cleaner has a rather convenient storage system in the body itself, where you can put all the necessary cleaning attachments.

The power consumption of the vacuum cleaner itself is within the normal range - 1500 W, which indicates the efficiency of the model. But the suction power is high - 320 W. It is quite enough to clean an average-sized apartment.

Dust and debris are collected in a fairly spacious bag with a capacity of three liters. This, of course, is very convenient, but the more the bag is filled, the worse the suction of the device.

The vacuum cleaner has a bag full indicator, which makes all cleaning quite simple.

The vacuum cleaner's equipment is very sparse, but familiar - a combined brush for crevices and dust removal.

pros

• high suction power;
• adequate price;
• there are places on the body for storing attachments;
• air blowing – available;
• The kit includes a crevice nozzle;
• roomy bag.

Minuses

• high noise level during operation;
• one brush included, albeit a combined one;
• lack of power regulator;
• Difficulty installing trash bag.

Samsung SC4140

Karcher VC 2

Karcher VC 2
In third place is a reliable model from the world-famous manufacturer of cleaning equipment for home and outdoors, Karcher. The VC2 model has shown itself only on the positive side, therefore it can safely be called effective and reliable, like all products of this company.

This vacuum cleaner has a classic type dust bag with a capacity of 2.8 liters. It’s not difficult to identify – the bag comes with a bright design. The power consumption of this model is quite low (1100 W).

On the body of the vacuum cleaner there is a suction power regulator, the strength of which varies depending on the cleaning location.

The pipe of this model is retractable and telescopic. This makes it easier to adjust the length of the working part.

The presence of a HEPA filter is fundamentally important - it makes it easier to clean the apartment, especially for allergy sufferers.

The vacuum cleaner's equipment is not too large - a basic combo brush, a narrow nozzle for difficult places and a soft brush for removal.

pros

• adequate price;
• high suction power;
• overheating protection system in the form of automatic shutdown of the vacuum cleaner;
• presence of a bag full indicator;
• spacious dust bag;
• high build quality;
• compactness.

Minuses

• short power cord;
• flimsy body;
• persistent smell of plastic;
• lack of power adjustment;
• makes a lot of noise.

Karcher VC 2

Video - Review of Karcher VC 2

Thomas SmartTouch Style

Thomas SmartTouch Style
Second place goes to the rather unusual SmartTouch Style model from the famous German manufacturer Thomas. And this particular model is the standard of power, silence and lightness.

The cost of this vacuum cleaner is quite justified: this model has many different attachments, which make cleaning large debris, cleaning hard-to-reach places - all this becomes very easy.

The suction power of this model is very high - 425 W. What's more surprising is the noise level. For this model it is 71 dB, which is considered quite small for vacuum cleaners.

It is worth noting the presence of an improved HEPA filter Blue Clean Air 13, which retains all dust. The MicroPor garbage and dust collection bag itself is quite spacious - three and a half liters and this volume is enough for three to four cleanings. And when purchasing such a vacuum cleaner, six of these bags are included.

Important! The main feature of the bags is the absorption of unpleasant odors.

There is an indicator on the body of this vacuum cleaner that lights up when the bag is completely filled. In addition, there is another indicator, but it is responsible for replacing the HEPA filter.

It is important to note the presence of engine protection in the form of a filter, which will increase the service life of the vacuum cleaner itself.

The THOMAS SmartTouch Style package is quite rich in attachments. There are several of them:

• for carpet/floor with a button that can be pressed with your foot;
• for cleaning through cracks;
• for cleaning mattresses;
• a brush attachment that can be used to clean polished furniture, bookshelves and various types of equipment;
• for cleaning wool.

In general, everyone will appreciate this vacuum cleaner. Men are for easy and quick cleaning, because they don’t want to spend a lot of time on it. Women are for power and silence.

pros

• high suction power;
• power consumption 2000 W (in this case, a high value is a plus, since the vacuum cleaner’s suction is very high;
• does not make too much noise, unlike previous vacuum cleaners;
• a spacious dust container that can absorb odors;
• presence of a HEPA 13 filter;
• The vacuum cleaner comes with a rich set of seven attachments.

Minuses

• There are few dust collectors (6 pieces included in the set), and it will be difficult to find later.

Thomas SmartTouch Style

Philips FC9174 Performer

Philips FC9174 Performer
The first place is occupied by a vacuum cleaner from the world-famous manufacturer Philips - FC9174 Performer. This model represents the ideal price/quality.

Although this vacuum cleaner falls into the “golden mean” in terms of price, it has a large number of different functions that are really necessary.

Let's talk about the main advantages. Firstly, the high suction power is 500 watts, which is a very high result among all vacuum cleaners in our rating. In this case, the vacuum cleaner consumes up to 2200 W. Secondly, the presence of a HEPA 13 fine filter will greatly help in cleaning for those who have allergies. Thirdly, a fairly capacious bag for collecting dust and debris. Fourthly – rich equipment. For example, a brush for furniture, for crevices and turbo.

Overall, this model is very interesting, and you should definitely pay attention to it when choosing.

Important! It is better to purchase disposable bags.

pros

• adequate price;
• high suction power – 500 Watt;
• spacious dust container (4 liters);
• equipment;
• high-quality assembly;
• telescopic handle;
• bag full indication;
• presence of power regulator.

Minuses

• no place to store brushes;
• consumables are needed;
• noisy;
• a bit heavy;
• consumes an extremely large amount of electricity.

Reviews and prices for Philips FC9174 Performer

Vacuum cleaner with aquafilter: helper or pest?

Vacuum cleaners with aquafilr are considered more hygienic models that are perfect for allergy sufferers. They pass polluted air through the water, dissolving dust and preventing it from escaping. But they also have their pros and cons.

Advantages:

• collect debris well that dissolves in water;
• do not require the purchase of bags;
• refresh and moisturize the air in the room;
• debris is easily removed: just pour out the dirty water.

Flaws:

• after each cleaning, such an electrical appliance must be disassembled, washed and left to dry unfolded, otherwise it will quickly become a source of fungus in the apartment;
• take up a lot of space when stored;
• do not cope well with debris that does not dissolve in water;
• if dust gets inside an air bubble, it is not filtered, but simply comes out when the bubble bursts;
• You need to use this model carefully: sharp turns, tilts and overturns lead to water spilling;
• it is necessary to monitor the amount of water and add it on time (sometimes right during cleaning);
• large dimensions.

Summarize. A vacuum cleaner with an aqua filter is convenient to use for general cleaning, as it copes with dirt and dust better than other models. But it is not at all suitable for small permanent cleanings: it takes too long to disassemble and wash it.

Some housewives have two types at once: one is simple for quickly putting the apartment in order, and the second is for general cleaning. Whether you want to become one of these housewives is up to you to decide.

Which vacuum cleaner is better: with a bag or a container?

Choosing a vacuum cleaner is fraught with some difficulties, and therefore you need to know the difference between two types of vacuum cleaners - classic with a bag and cyclone with a container.

Below we will reveal the difference between the two types in the form of a table.

Table No. 1. Difference between bagged and cyclone vacuum cleaners

There is a big difference between a cyclone and a bagged vacuum cleaner.
In fact, each type has its own pros and cons, which we will discuss below. Let's start with the bag version.

The main advantage of this type of vacuum cleaner is the ease of cleaning, as well as the ease of replacing the bag. The downside is the impossibility of normal replacement of reusable bags. Disposable bags are not like that - they practically do not get dirty. The procedure itself, however, is quite unpleasant for some.

It’s much easier with containers - just empty the container into the trash and you can put it back after cleaning. In general, cyclonic vacuum cleaners are considered the best.

The container is easy to clean, which is why people prefer cyclone vacuum cleaners

Vacuum cleaners with a garbage bag

The main feature of this vacuum cleaner is the presence of a dust bag. This is where debris will fall during cleaning. Such devices can cope with a wide range of work and have many functions. They are capable of cleaning carpets, curtains, furniture and other surfaces. Such vacuum cleaners can be either horizontal or vertical.

Bags for such vacuum cleaners are available in disposable and reusable versions. They differ in their production materials. Disposable ones are made of paper or synthetics. You will have to buy them additionally, because... After use, such bags are simply thrown away. They are made of durable paper that will hold up to 99% of dust. The volume can vary from 1.5 to 6 liters.

Reusable bags are made of fabric. They do not need to be changed and thrown away every time. You just need to pour out the garbage as it fills. In some models, these bags can be washed. It is also possible to make them yourself.

Nuances

If you choose a bagged vacuum cleaner, be sure to pay attention to the consumables. It should only be of high quality, because if you use bad bags, then there will be no point in cleaning - the garbage will be collected and immediately put out again. In addition, the bags must be durable, since improper installation or handling will damage them, even tear them.

Important! It is better not to turn on the vacuum cleaner until the dust collector is placed in it. Otherwise, you can simply break the device.

You need to work with a vacuum cleaner very carefully to avoid its breakdown.
When working with a cyclonic vacuum cleaner, you need to be careful - they sometimes give a serious shock. Of course, it won't kill, but it will definitely cause discomfort. The thing is that the plastic parts that form the basis of the tank are electrified due to the friction of the debris and the dust collector.

Important! It is better not to touch the vacuum cleaner itself during operation.

In addition, it should be noted that the HEPA filters of a cyclone vacuum cleaner are frequently changed. In this case, you need to find out whether it is possible to purchase a pure filter without other consumables. But at the same time, you need to remember about the existence of vacuum cleaners, the special design of which prevents frequent filter replacement.

HEPA filter - the weak point of the cyclone apparatus

Vacuum cleaners with bag

Well, who doesn’t know about vacuum cleaners with a bag? To be honest, this has long been the last century in our country.

Their biggest advantage is their affordable price and reliability.

For the rest...

The bag gets clogged quite quickly and you have to shake it out, while swallowing clouds of dust and sneezing. If the bag is not cleaned in time, the motor overheats and may burn out.

It cleans the surface well, of course, but some of the dust goes back into the room and settles on the furniture. This means that for allergy sufferers this technique is not the best choice.

If you do not suffer from respiratory diseases and are not embarrassed by the unpleasant procedure of emptying the dust bag, then you can purchase such a vacuum cleaner.

But when choosing, you should consider several important points:

• The bag should not be too small, otherwise you will have to empty it every five to six squares, and this is too troublesome.
• It’s better to take reusable bags, since you don’t know how many years you will use this vacuum cleaner. And since an incredible number of new products are released every year, they may simply stop being produced.
• Pay attention to the suction power. This is the most important parameter. As a rule, it is written not on the case, but in the technical passport and can differ significantly from the power consumption of electricity (what you see on the case).

By the way, in Europe to this day the most popular vacuum cleaners are of this type. Europeans do not need to use a reusable bag; they simply buy replacement ones, which are always in stock and cost little to them.

Cyclonic vacuum cleaners with container

We have previously written in detail about what a cyclone filter is in a vacuum cleaner. This is the same dust collector as a bag. Only it is hard and it is much easier to free it from dust, since you can simply rinse it under running water.

The air stream there is supplied in a cyclonic, vortex type and the dirt settles on the walls of the container. Moreover, there is usually a double container and the garbage is sorted by type: small and large.

This is very convenient, especially if there are small children in the house who constantly scatter things that can be accidentally grabbed while cleaning.

When cleaning, the container opens and you can clearly see what things got into it: they are not shrouded in a layer of fine dust.

Another plus: the vacuum cleaner does not overheat, even if the container is completely full. Usually the indicator simply lights up to indicate the need for cleaning.

But such vacuum cleaners also have disadvantages. In addition to the container, these devices are equipped with HEPA filters, which become very dirty with fine dust.

The force of the cyclonic vortex is not enough to draw it deep into the container and it settles on the filters. Therefore, they need to be changed quite often, and this is an extra expense.

So, which vacuum cleaner is better to buy for your home: with a bag or a container?

As you can see, both have their pros and cons. In one it is unpleasant to clean the bags, in the second you have to buy a filter. One overheats from a filled bag, and the second from a vortex interruption. In general, their strengths are equal.

The only thing that significantly distinguishes a cyclone-type vacuum cleaner from a regular one is that the collected dust does not return back to the room in such quantities.

That is, it can be purchased by those for whom dust is contraindicated for health reasons. But even then, not all models with containers are capable of this; you need to choose something more powerful and with enhanced filters.

Vacuum cleaners with aqua filter

Cyclonic vacuum cleaners with a filter differ from those with a dry container in that water is poured into it, which, with the help of an air flow, lifts the water and wets the filter. Dust is guaranteed to be retained, even the smallest, and will not get back into the room.

And thanks to this property, an aquafilter is necessary for allergy sufferers and asthmatics. In addition to this simple function, there are models for wet cleaning of the apartment. They cost more and weigh more.

If you choose between a vacuum cleaner with a regular container and this one, it is better to choose the second option.

They have one drawback: the need to change the filter frequently.

But the model with an aquafilter has more capabilities: thorough air purification from dust and mites, the ability to collect water from the floor with a vacuum cleaner, and the ability to wet clean.

Washing vacuum cleaners

A washing vacuum cleaner is usually a combined one. He “knows how” to do both wet and dry cleaning. The item is very convenient, but they are usually more expensive than other types.

The advantage of them is that you can wet clean carpets and furniture without straining too much.

The downside is the same frequent filter changes and the heaviness of the device. They weigh a lot more than regular ones.

There are also washing models that are not capable of dry cleaning. These can be purchased if you already have a regular vacuum cleaner.

Summary: it’s not worth taking them for daily cleaning of the apartment, since in the process it wets the surface and it takes a long time to dry. That is, you can still wash it once every couple of weeks, but why do you need a wet floor all the time (especially if you have laminate or parquet)?

Combination type vacuum cleaners: with bag and container

If you don’t want to buy a vacuum cleaner with a bag because it’s unpleasant to empty it, and you don’t want to buy a vacuum cleaner with a container because you need to change the filter often, then you can buy a combined option!

In this case, you can do cleaning by changing functions. For example, today you’re not too lazy to empty the bag - set this mode, and tomorrow you’ll use the container.

Or, you want to collect large garbage so that you can disassemble it later, then choose the mode with a container. This way, the filters become clogged less often and the dust bag doesn’t become terribly annoying.

And if you need cleaning at maximum power, switch to a bag. Because for some reason the cleaning mode with a bag is always much more powerful than the container mode.

Vacuum cleaners - robots

Robots are just a dream! Set the program and enjoy: drink coffee and the vacuum cleaner works.

Moreover, it does not need to be constantly turned on and off. It can be set up for six months and will clean as regularly as you want: twice a day or every few days.

Moreover, the program can be set even remotely, from work, for example. Just know, clean the container regularly!

The latest models even have recognition of surface type and degree of contamination. Plus, you can choose the cleaning mode and suction intensity yourself. Everything would be fine, but such a device is very expensive.

And it tends to break, like any equipment. But, if repairing a vacuum cleaner with a bag is not at all expensive, then with a robot it becomes more and more difficult and expensive. As a rule, the most important thing breaks down there, the “brain.”

But, if you are not short on funds and will not be upset if you have to repair it someday, then such a purchase will definitely please you. An obedient vacuum cleaner is sometimes much nicer than a housekeeper. Doesn't talk, isn't late...

Well, one last minus. Such a robot is capable of cleaning only surfaces to which there is easy access and room for maneuver.

The corners, in any case, will be dusty. But, in our opinion, these are mere trifles.

Voting: which cyclone or bagged vacuum cleaner is better?

Which cyclone or bagged vacuum cleaner would you choose or recommend purchasing?

BBK BV1503

16.67 % ( 2 )

VITEK VT-8105

0.00 % ( 0 )

Midea VCS43C4

8.33 % ( 1 )

LG VK76A02NTL

8.33 % ( 1 )

Samsung VC18M3160

0.00 % ( 0 )

Polaris PVC 1821WR

8.33 % ( 1 )

Philips FC9351 PowerPro Compact

8.33 % ( 1 )

Bosch BGS2UPWER3

0.00 % ( 0 )

Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Parquet CY26

0.00 % ( 0 )

Philips FC9174 Performer

8.33 % ( 1 )

Thomas SmartTouch Style

25.00 % ( 3 )

Karcher VC 2

0.00 % ( 0 )

Samsung SC4140

8.33 % ( 1 )

Vacuum cleaners with container

As many have realized, in such models the bag we are used to is replaced with a container . Models with containers are also called “cyclonic”. They began to be called that because when the vacuum cleaner operates, a cyclone actually forms inside the plastic container. All the dust remains on the walls of the tank, and after turning off the vacuum cleaner, it settles.

Such containers are most often transparent so that the degree of contamination can be easily determined during use. In more modern models, the tanks have several sections. All large debris gets into one of them, and finer dust into the other.

pros

As usual, let's start by looking at the advantages of cyclone vacuum cleaners .

• Economical. We have already discussed that buying disposable bags every time is quite problematic. Thanks to the container, you won’t have to make unnecessary expenses. When cleaning the vacuum cleaner, simply pull out the container, shake the contents into the trash and place the container back.
• Stable power. No matter how full the container is, the power of your vacuum cleaner will remain the same.
• No smell. Cyclone vacuum cleaners are almost completely odorless when cleaning. When using a bag, heated air passes through the bag of dust, resulting in a not very pleasant smell.
• Reservoir with departments. If you purchase a vacuum cleaner with such a container, you can easily find small lost items when cleaning. They will not be mixed with dust, but will end up in separate containers for larger debris.

Minuses

Unfortunately, such models have quite a few disadvantages . They do not cover all the positive aspects, but when choosing, they are also worth considering.

• Noise. Unlike bagged vacuum cleaners, cyclones are much noisier. Of course, it still depends on the model itself, but the fact remains a fact.
• Filters. One problem is the need to wash filters frequently. In addition, if you accidentally pinch the hose or pull in a large object, the stable air supply will be disrupted. This will lead to a failure of the cyclonic rotation, as a result of which the garbage will settle not in the container, but on the filter. The performance of the device will decrease accordingly.
• Container. The reservoir can be easily scratched by large debris. In addition, accidental breakage of the container will lead to big problems, since finding a new one is not so easy.
• Dimensions. Cyclone vacuum cleaners are larger in size, as the container takes up a lot of space. If you choose a small container, the vacuum cleaner will have to be cleaned after each use.

This is interesting! Which robot vacuum cleaner should you choose? Best models

Reviews

Let's move on to real reviews of cyclone models.

We had to repair the container vacuum cleaner because some small debris got into the impeller through the container and jammed it. As a result, the engine burned out. Why am I saying this? In some ways, these models are more convenient, but they have to be repaired more often. And this is more difficult to do than with bagged vacuum cleaners.

Vitaly

There was both a bagged and a cyclone vacuum cleaner. Each has its own pros and cons. A vacuum cleaner with a bag is more convenient to use, but buying bags becomes more and more expensive over time. There is no such problem with a container. Of course, in the advertising videos, such vacuum cleaners have some advantages, but in reality they are more difficult to clean and are noisier.

Anya

Rating of cyclone vacuum cleaners

There are also very good models among container vacuum cleaners. Let's move on to the top 3 best models of cyclone vacuum cleaners .

1. Samsung SC4520. One of the cheapest models among cyclone vacuum cleaners. The suction power is 350 W. Ideal for those who want to purchase an inexpensive model with a container, without any additional functions. It is advisable to wash the filters after each use.
2. Bosch BGS 62530. Very quiet model, especially considering the strong suction power of 550 W. Does a great job cleaning the room. A bit inconvenient to use as it weighs 8kg. The dimensions are also not small, so this model is suitable for those who have free space to store a vacuum cleaner.
3. Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Animal Pro. Quite a high price, but the model has a large number of advantages and good reviews. A special feature of the model is the body, which ensures a stable position. Even when the vacuum cleaner tips over, it immediately returns to its place. There are many attachments available. The company provides a five-year warranty.

We hope that after reading all the information, reading reviews and looking at the rating, it will be much easier for you to make your choice and choose the most suitable model for you. Happy shopping.