Rating of the TOP 7 best membrane keyboards: which one to choose, pros and cons, reviews

Rating of the TOP 10 best membrane keyboards of 2021

What is a membrane keyboard?

A classic membrane keyboard consists of a thin silicone or rubber gasket under each key, resembling an inverted cap..

When the key is pressed completely, the cap is “pressed” and closes the circuit of contacts, that is, the key is activated and the signal is transmitted to the computer.

These are the keyboards that are installed on the vast majority of laptops, and the majority of “office” keyboards in the low price range have a membrane switch device.

Other household appliances are also equipped with the same keyboards: multicookers, vacuum cleaners and other devices with “touch” controls.

The advantages of membrane keyboards, in addition to affordable cost, include almost complete noiselessness, the thinnest design possible (no thicker than a regular sheet of paper) and flexibility, even the device can be rolled up.

Among the shortcomings, it is worth noting the absent or extremely weak tactile feedback, which is solved by manufacturers by using a more expensive “scissor” mechanism (mainly on laptops), as well as by adding “sound” effects from pressing.

The main disadvantage of a membrane keyboard is rapid wear and tear and a fairly short service life, which - nevertheless - ranges from 1 to 10 million keystrokes, which - with average intensity - is at least 1-3 years.

Mechanical keyboards.

A mechanical keyboard and the principle of its operation are fundamentally different from a membrane one. If you remove the keycaps (keycaps on which the symbols are printed), you can see the switches. A switch is precisely the mechanism responsible for registering keystrokes on a mechanical keyboard.

The switch itself consists of several components:

1. Case - black or transparent, if there is regular or RGB backlighting,
2. Stem (with slider) - this part is pressed and opens the contacts inside the switch,
3. Contacts - they close and open, there are different designs,
4. Spring - returns the stem with the slider to its original position, opening the contacts.

It is when the metal contacts in a mechanical keyboard are closed that a press is registered. This method is more durable than the membrane. It is also worth mentioning that there are several videos of mechanical switches from different companies. They are divided into two types: Cherry-like and others.

Switches (switches) of the “Cherry” type include Cherry, Kailh, Gateron, Outemu themselves. They have the same stem mount for the same keycap mount. All custom keycaps and the vendors that produce them have a cross-shaped mount.

Some gaming peripheral manufacturers release their mechanical keyboards on other switches. The principle of their operation will still be similar to Cherry, but it will be very difficult to find custom keycaps for them.

The implementation of backlighting in mechanical keyboards is fundamentally different from membrane ones: a separate LED is soldered into each switch, which will be responsible for backlighting a separate key. The LED can be located either in the switch itself or on the board.

Video with backlight test of a mechanical keyboard.

Many users think in stereotypes about mechanical keyboards, as if they are always expensive, have a high profile and are loud, unlike membrane ones. And all of the above stereotypes have become false, and the most affordable mechanical keyboard can long ago be bought on Aliexpress at a reasonable price.

If you are a fan of low-profile keys, then among mechanics, some vendors have long been producing keyboards with short switch travel. The tactile sensations from pressing will be the same as using a laptop keyboard.

The key in mechanical keyboards registers the press much earlier than in membrane ones, the very feeling of use will be more pleasant, and the service life will be up to 50 times longer. RGB backlighting can be configured for an individual key as you please.

The best manufacturers of mechanical keyboards are considered to be Leopold and Varmilo, these are top Chinese brands; price tags for products vary from 8 to 23 thousand rubles.

In this case, the price justifies the means: the keys are pressed clearly and evenly, without unpleasant clicks or rattling echoes, and most importantly, there is no play (they do not wobble in different directions). Varmilo keyboard switches are well lubricated from the factory and it is extremely pleasant to work with such a device, especially due to the thick PBT plastic (PBT, Poly Butylene Terephthalate) with a rough surface, which does not wear off over time, and also muffles the sound of the keycap hitting the switch.

The best membrane keyboards

Logitech Corded Keyboard K280e Black USB

Classic wired keyboard with ultra-thin design easily connects to your desktop or laptop.

It is equipped with a standard set of keys with a familiar number pad, which does not require additional training from the user in order to “get used to” the new device.

The keyboard is almost completely protected from moisture, that is, it is not afraid of accidentally spilled coffee or juice.

Ideal for an office or personal computer for a primary school student.

This model has proven itself well in 2021.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 459x20x183;
• weight, kg - 0.934;
• type - classic, with digital pad;
• number of keys - 104;
• additionally - ultra-thin design, moisture protection.

pros

• good assembly;
• stylish design;
• It’s easy and pleasant to type due to the classic layout and short key travel.

Minuses

• Function key markings are not too noticeable;
• long keys are “noisy”;
• The Russian alphabet is not highlighted in color.

A4Tech Bloody B120 Black USB

The keyboard is positioned as a gaming one - and indeed, the device is equipped with a dedicated reinforced WSAD unit, rubberized relief keys, a palm rest and adjustable backlighting, the level of which can be adjusted based on user preferences and workplace illumination.

A nice addition is that the package includes additional keys. It features fast response and almost complete protection from water.

It will be an ideal gift for a teenager or a rather successful home keyboard for a computer game lover.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 458x37x180;
• weight, kg - 0.8;
• type - classic, with digital pad;
• number of keys - 104;
• additionally - customizable backlight.

pros

• comfortable and quiet;
• pleasant lighting;
• protection from water.

Minuses

• the paint is erased from the keys;
• does not recognize simultaneous key presses (which is necessary in games);
• illumination is uneven.

Logitech Wireless Keyboard K360 Black USB

An almost flat wireless laptop keyboard, compact and comfortable, will be an excellent purchase for students or those who work from home.

Stylish design, classic layout and no frills make the device comfortable to use for both standard typing and small gaming battles.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 382x24x158;
• weight, kg - 0.8;
• type - classic;
• wireless communication type - radio channel, range 10 m;
• power supply - 2 x AA;
• number of keys - 110 main, 6 additional;
• additionally - volume control, digital block.

pros

• stylish;
• wireless;
• there are additional keys.

Minuses

• large key travel;
• short left “shift”, small arrow keys;
• Function keys are not grouped.

Logitech Wireless Keyboard K270 Black USB

An elegant wireless keyboard made in a classic design with a comfortable, familiar layout and grouping of keys is perhaps the best choice for any user.

Additional keys will allow you to easily launch a browser, email client, or control the volume and playback of tracks, as well as send your computer to sleep mode by pressing one button on the keyboard.

The bend in the lower part of the case makes it possible to make the lower keys larger and more comfortable for constant use.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 442 x 150 x 18;
• weight, kg - 0.5;
• type - classic;
• type of wireless communication - radio channel;
• power supply - 2 x AAA;
• number of keys - 112 main, 8 additional;
• additionally - digital block.

pros

• standard classic;
• no Num and Scroll Lock indicators;
• wireless.

Minuses

• Cyrillic and Latin - in the same color;
• noisy;
• the buttons glare.

A4Tech X7-G800 Black-Silver PS/2

Another wired keyboard (PS/2 connector), which has a distinct “gaming” design, but at the same time performs equally well both in ordinary “office” typing and in exciting gaming adventures.

A very stylish and ergonomic design combined with an extremely affordable price make the device ideal for teenagers and young adults who are passionate about computer games.

The keyboard has a high degree of moisture protection, dedicated “game” blocks, additional customizable keys (for game macros), adjustable response speed and an attractive appearance that definitely attracts attention.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 513x18x210;
• weight, kg - 1.0;
• type - classic;
• number of keys - 120 main, 16 additional;
• additionally - protection from moisture, colored “game” blocks, changing the response speed, reconfiguring the assignment of “game” keys.

pros

• comfortable;
• unique properties of changing response speed and reconfiguring WASD;
• rubberized gaming keys.

Minuses

• no backlight;
• “slippery” key coating;
• short "space".

Logitech K380 Multi-Device Black Bluetooth

The ultra-thin wireless keyboard designed for a tablet features round, convex buttons and bright yellow function keys, making it a desirable purchase for young people and teenagers who value minimal size and stylish appearance as much as ease of use and good functionality.

Also, the advantages of the device include quiet operation of the keys and very beautiful colors.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (L x W x H, mm) - 279 x 124 x 16;
• weight, kg - 0.423;
• design - classic;
• wireless connection type - Bluetooth (radius 10 m);
• power supply - 2 x AAA;
• number of keys - 79;
• functionality - no digital block.

pros

• tactilely pleasant key surface;
• works with several devices simultaneously;
• high functionality, ability to customize macros.

Minuses

• short "shift";
• The UK layout is used as a basis.

Logitech Wireless Touch Keyboard K400 Plus Black USB

Slim wireless keyboard with touchpad is ideal for controlling your TV or media player.

Classic dimensions and layout, light weight and large range of action allow you to carry the device anywhere in the room.

Convenient: no need to use an additional device - a standard computer mouse.

Suitable for those who are used to using a TV screen instead of a computer monitor.

The model does not lose its relevance in 2021.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x D x H, mm) - 354 x 140 x 24;
• weight, kg - 0.38;
• design - classic;
• type of wireless communication - radio channel;
• number of keys - 85;
• functionality - touchpad, no digital pad, power supply 2 x AA.

pros

• light and comfortable;
• pleasant key coverage, good response;
• there is a touchpad.

Minuses

• no backlight;
• The touchpad is weakly sensitive.

Logitech G G213 Prodigy Black USB

An ergonomic gaming keyboard that is ideal for regular typing . The classic design and very impressive and bright lighting of the gaming areas attract increased attention to the device, allowing you to play in complete darkness.

At the same time, the user can independently customize the backlighting of each of the 5 “gaming” key blocks, choosing from more than 16.8 million shades.

The keys have a perfectly soft and smooth stroke and have a noticeable feedback when pressed, which is not too typical for membrane keyboards.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (L x W x H, mm) - 452 x 218 x 33;
• weight, kg - 1.0;
• design - classic;
• number of keys - 112 main / 8 additional;
• functionality - setting up zone backlighting of keys, numeric keypad, volume control, protection from water and dust.

pros

• ergonomic, comfortable;
• bright but soft illumination, comfortable for the eyes;
• Pleasant key press and response.

Minuses

• noisy;
• easily soiled key cover;
• restrictions on the principle of backlight selection.

A4Tech B314 Black USB

A stylish wired gaming keyboard made in a “space” design will surely appeal to children and teenagers.

The ergonomic shape and wrist rest will allow your hands not to get tired during long games, and the bright, customizable LED backlight illuminates the keys efficiently even in the dark, without causing discomfort to the eyes.

It has an extremely short response time - only 0.2 ms, which will certainly come in handy in gaming battles.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x H x D, mm) - 495x42x240;
• weight, kg - 1.02;
• type - classic;
• number of keys - 109 main, 5 additional;
• additionally - digital keypad, customizable key backlighting.

pros

• backlight;
• price;
• quality.

Minuses

• no instructions;
• if the keyboard is not active, the backlight starts blinking;
• Russian letters are written in a “transparent” font.

Logitech Craft Advanced keyboard Gray Bluetooth

Ultra-thin wireless keyboard features classic dimensions, a universal control dial and an optimized design.

Designed for those who spend a lot of time playing computer games.

Characterized by instant access to the necessary functions, fast response, quiet key operation.

An interesting feature is that the backlight intensifies as the hands approach the device and weakens if the user moves away from the keyboard.

It is worth noting that this is one of the best models of 2021.

Characteristics:

• dimensions (W x D x H, mm) - 430 x 149 x 32;
• weight, kg - 0.96;
• design - classic;
• wireless connection type - Bluetooth (radius 10 m);
• number of keys - 109 main, 5 additional;
• functionality - backlit keys, number pad, Apple layout, scroll wheel.

pros

• minimalist design;
• soft comfortable lighting;
• allows you to connect up to 3 wireless devices simultaneously.

Minuses

• the scroll wheel is poorly thought out;
• high price;
• There are no indicators for individual keys.

Premium keyboards

APPLE MAGIC KEYBOARD WITH NUMERIC KEYPAD

An excellent option for users who are looking to find the optimal model of a membrane-type keyboard that works via Bluetooth. It has a classic design, characterized by insignificant key travel, which ensures low operating volume. The space bar is secured securely, even after a long period of active use it does not become loose, and will continue to work just as silently. The kit includes a charging cable that powers the keyboard via a USB connector, so the user does not have to worry that the device will run out of power at the most inopportune moment. According to the American company that created this gadget, the keyboard can work in autonomous mode for about one month on a single battery charge.

More: Top 10 best server hosting

The keys are secured using scissor technology. The travel of each button is only a few millimeters. No phantom clicks or false positives were detected during testing. The keyboard itself operates completely silently; only natural slaps will be heard, indicating the touch of your fingers to the buttons. The model is completely universal: thanks to its minimal response time, it will be quite suitable for use during games, but this device is also great for typing, composing programs, and so on.

Advantages:

• Excellent workmanship and assembly quality;
• The keys are located at the optimal distance from each other;
• Stably picks up the Bluetooth signal;
• Pleasant to the touch;
• Does not slip on the table surface;
• Compact overall dimensions and low weight.

Flaws:

• No backlight provided.

APPLE MAGIC KEYBOARD WITH NUMERIC KEYPAD

Razer Cynosa Chroma Black USB

This model has been on the computer peripheral market for more than a year and a half. During this time, it managed to gain popularity among diverse users - programmers, computer game enthusiasts, office workers, and so on. There is an original LED backlight, which provides uniform illumination of both Cyrillic and Latin characters. In addition, even the space between the keys is illuminated, and the backlight itself can be synchronized with any peripheral devices produced by this manufacturer. The design is strict and precise. The case is made of high-quality matte plastic; no fingerprints, dirt or dust will remain on it. The set of keys is standard, a number pad is provided. Even the traditionally large buttons are made only slightly larger here, which has a positive effect on the ergonomics of the model.

The symbols are applied using laser engraving, so they will not be erased even with intensive use of the model. Due to the rubberized feet, the keyboard stands on the surface as stable as possible; it is quite natural that there are feet. There are drainage holes that are great for removing dirt that has accumulated between the buttons. The device is connected to the computer using a regular cable; it does not provide any additional protection. Its length is quite enough to place the device at a considerable distance from the PC.

Advantages:

• There is a special wrist rest that makes working with the keyboard very comfortable;
• Adjustable backlight levels;
• The keys are pressed quite accurately and have little travel.

Flaws:

• Quite expensive.

Razer Cynosa Chroma Black USB

HyperX Alloy Elite RGB (Cherry MX Red) Black USB

The product is housed in a reliable housing made of high-quality lightweight aluminum alloy. The buttons are slightly raised above the working surface. In general, the appearance is very stylish, this keyboard looks premium, it is not similar to any model included in our review of the best silent keyboards today. This equipment comes complete with a special stand, which is secured with a pair of hooks. On it you can find a neat textured pattern that does not allow fingers and wrists to slide across the surface. The upper part has a slight thickening. In the upper left corner you can find three mechanical buttons responsible for controlling the brightness of the backlight, switching to game mode, and so on.

The keys are made of matte plastic, the letters are applied by laser engraving. Several buttons have a steel pattern - this applies to those that are most actively involved in gaming processes. The backlight is as uniform as possible, and the space between the keys is also illuminated. It is quite natural that in the lower part there are two folding legs, and there are also rubber linings. The connection cable is quite massive, placed in a fabric braid, the area where it comes out of the keyboard is reinforced and reliably protected from fracture. Connects to a personal computer via a high-speed USB 3.0 interface, which ensures minimal response time.

Advantages:

• Metal body;
• Original LED backlight over the entire keyboard area;
• Availability of a removable armrest;
• Works very quietly;
• There are options for managing multimedia processes.

Flaws:

• High price.

HyperX Alloy Elite RGB (Cherry MX Red) Black USB

How to choose and what to pay attention to?

When choosing a membrane keyboard, you should pay attention to the following points:

• purpose of use : for normal office work, a keyboard with a traditional layout, convenient enter and space buttons and a minimal set of function keys is sufficient, but for games or working with specialized programs, you should choose a gaming keyboard with reinforced blocks, backlighting and a lot of additional functionality;
• the nature of the keys' response - it should be clear, understandable and predictable; if there is no tactile response from pressing, it will be inconvenient to use such a keyboard for constant work or play;
• key stroke (pressure depth for the required operation) - here it is worth choosing the minimum value: 2-2.5 mm is considered optimal, but 3-4 mm will not cause much strain on the fingers, it is also worth “touching” the keyboard - pressing the keys usually requires a force that varies from 35-45 g to 60-80 g, and the user himself needs to try the pressing force - for some, “light” pressing is more convenient, while others like a clearer and more intelligible “heavy” pressing;
• if the keyboard will be used for complex games , it should be able to recognize the simultaneous pressing of several keys, but for “office” keyboards this indicator is not important;
• pleasant sensations from the keys - fingers should not slide on the surface, it is better if the surface of the keys is rough;
• ergonomics and strength of the case - these indicators can only be confirmed by long-term use, so if the user did not have such keyboards at his disposal, then one can only be guided by the manufacturer’s description;
• manufacturer - you should give preference to a well-known brand that guarantees the quality and durability of the device.

Rating updated September 12, 2021.